View comments by: Most Recent - first / last | Most Popular - first / last | Replies - hide / show

Should we abandon marriage?

Marriage is quite unnatural as people are neither emotionally, nor, psychologically programmed to stay with the same person for decades. The fact that more than half of marriages end in divorce bears this out. Is it now time to call for an end to this silly tradition?


Created By on 05/06/2016

Not a member?

You need to be a member to interact with Silversurfers. Joining is free and simple to do. Click the button below to join today!

beneDictus
26th Sep 2016 12:37:11
4
Thanks for voting!
No. I don`t think that it`s unnatural at all. As for not being emotionally, or psychologically programmed, ...i would have to disagree with that, as well. I would have thought that the very opposite would be the actual case. Let`s face it. Everyone has an intrinsic requirement to feel emotionally connected with that special someone. And, marriage, as an institution, serves only to reinforce that bond. It isn`t easy, of course. It`s something to be worked at..continuously. But, with a sufficient amount of commitment and dedication towards each other, the many and varied complex challenges can be overcome. But, the most important ingredient is, of course...LOVE...Most people are emotionally programmed to be loved, and to love in return. Those who are not...are missing out on something extremely vital to one`s life force.
Response from celtwitch Original Poster made on 26th Sep 2016 13:51:43
If it has to be 'worked at' it isn't natural, and 'LOVE' can die as quickly as it came into existence.
And, calling marriage an 'institution' makes it sound very unnatural, as indeed it is, why would anyone in their right mind want to spend the rest of their life with the same person?
Love might be ancillary, but it certainly isn't vital.
Response from beneDictus made on 28th Sep 2016 12:38:00
To answer the original question...should marriage be abandoned...Most definitely not. I stand by what i said before. Why would anyone in their right mind want to spend the rest of his, or her life with the same person...? Well..duh...maybe it has something to do with the fact that they have a profound LOVE for that person. And...oh...think of the emotional security which comes with the package. Has to be experienced to be believed.
As for the apparent fragile nature of love...that it can actually DIE...am still trying to get my head around THAT little snippet. I thought it was as perennial as the grass. One can strangle it...suffocate it...suppress it...deny that it was ever there...glue a stick of dynamite to it, and try to blow it up. But, it can never be killed.
I rest my case. Amen.
Response from celtwitch Original Poster made on 28th Sep 2016 17:11:32
I think it was Socrates who said the 'the most enduring hatred is one that has been preceded by great love.' I may not have quoted verbatim, but you get the drift.
Love does die. I have a daughter who robbed me 7 years ago, she is the most unpleasant, deceitful person I have ever known. I woke up one morning and realised I no longer love her.
I have never know sexual/ relationship love, and I wonder how anyone can claim to be 'in love.'
I have known plenty of 'lusty' relationships, is that the same as love?
Response from beneDictus made on 3rd Oct 2016 11:30:56
No. That isn`t the kind of love which i was referring to. Not the love which usually comprises the ''in love'' situation. It`s something else...which has the potential to transcend all boundaries and human emotions.
Response from celtwitch Original Poster made on 3rd Oct 2016 12:04:12
I think the 'in love' situation is short lived, you can't remain 'in love' with someone indefinitely, it's unnatural and unnecessary. Have sex and move on.
Response from beneDictus made on 4th Oct 2016 11:20:17
That`s just white washing the whole issue. It`s only people who have the inability to both nurture and sustain a loving relationship, who conveniently condemn it. Those who strive for higher ideals are searching for something much more fundamental in life. Have sex, and move on...? Move on to what...? Must get pretty meaningless, after a while, to have a seemingly endless series of sexual encounters...most of which are driven by social conditioning and expectation, anyway.
Sandy 58
9th Jun 2016 00:46:10 (Last activity: 3rd Mar 2019 12:57:56)
3
Thanks for voting!
I don't think marriage is unnatural if you are with the right person. I think life was simpler when families survived in council houses, no car, no savings, no computers, no smart phone, living from one week to the next. All the money went into the one pot. That was the norm for most and divorce rate was minimal. Sticking together through thick and thin was what marriage was about.
But it's a new world and finding the right person that you can trust with your life and your money may be getting more difficult. People are becoming more full of self interest.
But I think most people would want to have that special someone who will be there for them till death do you part.
That may not fit for everyone. But if it became the norm to have no marriage, and people to have 3 or 4 relationships over their lifetime, would we then have children with the same mother but different fathers and less divorce but more court battles over custody or maintenance payments.
Response from KEITH_WL made on 9th Jun 2016 12:27:41
Well put.
Response from georgesmum made on 9th Jun 2016 14:16:15
You are so right....nowadays we expect too much and give too little!
Response from jeanmark made on 3rd Mar 2019 12:57:56
Well put MaryPoppins, women in particular found it hard to leave a difficult marriage because of the way society viewed such things and initially having no way to support themselves and their children.
[deleted]
6th Jun 2016 20:54:58 (Last activity: 29th Oct 2018 17:16:05)
3
Thanks for voting!
[deleted]
Response from celtwitch Original Poster made on 8th Jun 2016 11:14:11
How 2 people can stay together for decades has always puzzled me, I mean, why would you want to stick around with someone for most of your life?
What happens when your true love comes home blootered, develops halitosis, puts on 5 stones in weight, spends most of his time with his pigeons, and dresses like a scarecrow, do you still love him?
I think that married people just lack the courage to stand on their own 2 feet, they are too scared too scared of being alone.
Response from georgesmum made on 8th Jun 2016 16:14:08
Oh celtwitch those words ar so harsh......after all none of us are perfect.......your post did make me chuckle though, thinking of a scarecrow and his pigeons!
Response from Bella479 made on 11th Jan 2017 20:37:28
yes....there is something to be said about being "too scared to stand on their own" . The longer a person is married the longer they stay that way. I did that and so wish I would have flew the nest years ago. Being married to someone with so many hangups and childhood problems has dragged me down. After 47 years I am sick of waiting for him to shed the 'pity party' and grow up. We had 2 children but I mothered 3....he had no interest in sex and this caused such a rejection feeling in me. It is amazing to read others saying marriage is not necessary because this concept has reality to it.
Response from RayJ made on 8th Sep 2017 16:44:37
Well celtwich that made me laugh.
I don't get home blooted and haven't put on 5 stone in weight. I consider myself to be of athletic physique. I don't have pigeons and would you believe I don't like football either. Though I do have a pint ort two.
We do things together as well as separately with our pals.
Usually before I go out on my own I ask for approval of the way I'm dressed. I want my wife to be pleased she has a smart husband. On many occasions I've been described as dapper in my dress.
In my career I was in structural engineering, I was a travelling man. So we spent quite a lot of time separated.
We are into our 57th year and still happy, even if I do like to flirt a little.
Response from Stayingzen made on 29th Oct 2018 17:16:05
Men should never stop flirting imo
Stayingzen
29th Oct 2018 17:06:28
0
Thanks for voting!
This is the ending to your life's story folks. Either you stay and keep getting bitter or you walk away and deal with loss. Too late to sit on the fence so to speak...OR...stay and fully accept your choice. Start by being open, candid and honest about what your needs are. Just mho
David46
16th Aug 2018 06:20:04
1
Thanks for voting!
Most marriages go through periods of highs and lows. If you are not married you can walk away easily into the sunset and try again or life the single life. However when you look back on what you had, the good times you shared you are left with regrets. You marry someone because they become the most important person in your life and you want to be with them forever. I know people change and things can get difficult, but work through your problems because somewhere inside your spouse is the person you fell in love with, don't throw it all away because you may end up regretting it.
RayJ
8th Sep 2017 16:26:38
1
Thanks for voting!
There's no need to call an end to it. Most folk these days partner up first then get married if they choose to, even after a number of children have arrived.
Marriage is a choice two people make.
In my teens a lot of marriages were because of whups!
Why call an end to it, maybe your statistics are correct but on the day there are two very happy people. Don't forget the beer later.
There are other creatures in nature that partner up for life, though I haven't seen them get married or divorced.
jeanmark
9th Jun 2016 14:51:48 (Last activity: 11th Jan 2017 20:25:39)
11
Thanks for voting!
I neither think marriage is unnatural or silly. The fact you don't consider it right for you doesn't mean it isn't right for other people. You may not be emotionally or psychologically programmed to remain with one person for decades but many of us find that a comfort and it isn't because we are afraid to be alone. Divorce rates may appear to be high but could that relate to the people themselves rather than the 'tradition' of marriage?
Response from KEITH_WL made on 10th Jun 2016 19:30:08
Well put.
Response from Treehugger1 made on 26th Sep 2016 17:42:31
Good point Jeanmark.
Response from celtwitch Original Poster made on 29th Sep 2016 11:48:19
No, it's not 'the people themselves' it's marriage that causes divorce, i.e. don't get married and then you won't have to go through divorce.
Marriage, and long term painful marriage specifically, is both unnatural and unnecessary.
Being married isn't living, it's existing in a fog of misery, having to deal with the farts and the soiled underwear of someone who treats you like a slave, but who you 'claim' to be in love with.
Give me the single life, thank you.
Response from jeanmark made on 14th Oct 2016 19:06:52
That is being pedantic celtwitch, the fact you have a negative experience of marriage doesn't make the concept of marriage wrong or outdated, just your perception. I am certainly not a slave and would consider our partnership as equal in all ways, but then that's my experience and consider myself fortunate to have found a soul mate.
Response from Bella479 made on 11th Jan 2017 20:25:39
If I would do over I would never get married ... we just come from two different IQs and backgrounds. I struggle a great deal with understanding the concept of marriage, always have. Thought we should have children so we had two at a young age they are very successful adults who have no care for us. People these days do not realize marriage is not worth the effort and tears...just my opinion. I should have put my hormones in the closet and stuck it out single...would have been so much more content and healthier. Just had heart surgery I know due to stress from husband and adult children. Stay single, happy and healthy.
celtwitch Original Poster
28th Sep 2016 17:12:16 (Last activity: 14th Oct 2016 19:09:56)
3
Thanks for voting!
Marriage is the number one cause for divorce!
Response from jeanmark made on 14th Oct 2016 19:09:56
As you have already stated, you can not get divorced unless you are married so your statement is actually correct.
[deleted]
3rd Oct 2016 17:00:29
2
Thanks for voting!
sonroy
28th Sep 2016 12:43:04
3
Thanks for voting!
Have to agree with be beneDictus could not have put it better, well said
Muzak53
26th Sep 2016 03:51:36
1
Thanks for voting!
My wife and i divorced after 30 years there were many faults most of which sadly to say were mine. We are still friends and i support her finically in addition to her income. The thing is if you try everything and nothing works you cant expect the other person to forget or forgive. You cant control another persons mind. Hopefully time will heal. The person that says and does hurtfull things has to live with thier self.
KEITH_WL
6th Jun 2016 22:11:35 (Last activity: 9th Aug 2016 03:49:12)
5
Thanks for voting!
It's one thing to disagree with others' beliefs; something else to call them silly. After 52 years marriage still works well for my wife and me.
Response from celtwitch Original Poster made on 7th Jun 2016 11:50:59
52 years married to the same person! It sounds like a fate worse than death.
Response from georgesmum made on 8th Jun 2016 16:07:19
And here's to many more happy years together!
Response from Lib made on 9th Aug 2016 03:49:12
I was married once for 12 years. Never remarried as I had children and didn't feel up to putting my children though a series of relationships or burden them or myself with an outside person suggesting how they should be raised. So, I stayed single. It seems there is a time and place for marriage. Some people want and need a partner to get through life and others do not. It seems silly to fault folks for wanting a marriage under the right circumstances and silly to fault folks who choose to remain unmarried. What does anger me is the discrimination single parent must deal with. In the USA single folks to do not get the same tax breaks as married folks. Why? Insurance is most instances is more expensive. Why? There seems to be a belief that married folks are more responsible which makes me laugh. Doesn't the sheer fact that they are sharing the load of life with someone else demand less? If a spouse loses a job the other spouse can hopefully work and help out. A dependant child cannot. The point to my rambling is simply this. There should not be a reward or a punishment based on marital status. Those who want marriage should be married and those who do not, should not be required to marry. Not everyone is marriage material! No, I am not gay such a female who did not want to force some strange guy onto her children. And no I did not receive child support or the family home. Anyone would be hard pressed to undermine my sense of accomplishment or belief in myself. More importantly all four of my girls know they can do whatever they set their minds too. 2 are housewives and 2 are college educated but all four made the decisions they felt were best for them.
Joan Fraser
10th Jun 2016 20:52:08
1
Thanks for voting!
I would never get married again, but share the joy of couples who stay the course in happy loving relationships. Religion, faith, belief, emotion and love, as well as personal standards/values, or expectation all play a part, and I certainly couldn't call those factors silly albeit I don't sign up to them all

Community Terms & Conditions

Content standards

These content standards apply to any and all material which you contribute to our site (contributions), and to any interactive services associated with it.

You must comply with the spirit of the following standards as well as the letter. The standards apply to each part of any contribution as well as to its whole.

Contributions must:

be accurate (where they state facts); be genuinely held (where they state opinions); and comply with applicable law in the UK and in any country from which they are posted.

Contributions must not:

contain any material which is defamatory of any person; or contain any material which is obscene, offensive, hateful or inflammatory; or promote sexually explicit material; or promote violence; promote discrimination based on race, sex, religion, nationality, disability, sexual orientation or age; or infringe any copyright, database right or trade mark of any other person; or be likely to deceive any person; or be made in breach of any legal duty owed to a third party, such as a contractual duty or a duty of confidence; or promote any illegal activity; or be threatening, abuse or invade another’s privacy, or cause annoyance, inconvenience or needless anxiety; or be likely to harass, upset, embarrass, alarm or annoy any other person; or be used to impersonate any person, or to misrepresent your identity or affiliation with any person; or give the impression that they emanate from us, if this is not the case; or advocate, promote or assist any unlawful act such as (by way of example only) copyright infringement or computer misuse.

Nurturing a safe environment

Our Silversurfers community is designed to foster friendships, based on trust, honesty, integrity and loyalty and is underpinned by these values.

We don't tolerate swearing, and reserve the right to remove any posts which we feel may offend others... let's keep it friendly!